What's New

Transparency and Accountability 2.0

Relevance

• GS Paper 2  Important Aspects of Governance, Transparency and Accountability, E-governance- applications, models, successes, limitations, and potential; Citizens Charters, Transparency & Accountability and institutional and other measures.
• Tags: #transparency #accountability #PublicAdministration #civilservants #governance.

Transparency and accountability are two important concepts often associated with governance, business practices, and ethical conduct.

What is Transparency?

Transparency refers to the quality or state of being open, honest, and easily understood or perceived by others. In various contexts, such as government, organizations, or businesses, transparency implies a willingness to share information, data, processes, and decisions with the public, stakeholders, or relevant parties.

Transparent practices help build trust, promote ethical behavior, and allow for scrutiny, which is crucial for accountability. Transparency can encompass financial transparency, transparency in decision-making, and the disclosure of relevant information to stakeholders.

Transparency consists of 

• Openness: Being open and accessible in operations, decision-making, and information sharing.
• Disclosure: Providing clear and honest information to the public, stakeholders, or relevant parties.
• Accountability: Promoting accountability by allowing scrutiny and oversight of actions and processes.
• Trust: Building trust among stakeholders through clear and truthful communication.
• Ethical Conduct: Encouraging ethical behavior and discouraging hidden agendas or practices.
• Good Governance: A fundamental principle of good governance in various contexts, including government and organizations.

What is Accountability?

Accountability refers to the obligation or willingness of individuals, organizations, or institutions to take responsibility for their actions, decisions, and the consequences of their conduct.  It involves being answerable for one’s behavior and the outcomes of one’s actions.

Accountability is a key element in ensuring that those in positions of power or authority are held responsible for their actions and that they can be called to account for any misconduct or negligence.

Accountability entails

• Responsibility: Taking responsibility for one’s actions, decisions, and their consequences.
• Answerability: Being answerable to relevant parties, stakeholders, or authorities.
• Oversight: Involving mechanisms for oversight, monitoring, and evaluation.
• Consequences: Accepting consequences, including sanctions or penalties, for failing to meet obligations.
• Trustworthiness: Building trust by demonstrating reliability and integrity in fulfilling commitments.
• Transparency: Often requires transparent reporting and disclosure of actions and outcomes. 

Need for Transparency in Public Administration

Transparency in public administration is crucial for several reasons, as it promotes accountability, builds trust, and ensures the efficient and ethical functioning of government institutions.

India emphasized open, transparent governance. Policies were developed collaboratively, posted online for public input. Initiatives like Garib Kalyan Melas aimed to deliver development benefits directly to the needy. “One Day Governance” provided time-bound e-governance services under the Citizens’ Charter.

• Accountability: Transparency holds public officials accountable for their actions and decisions. When government activities are open to scrutiny, officials are less likely to engage in corrupt or unethical behavior.
  • For Example: Financial transparency in government budgets and expenditures allows citizens to track how public funds are allocated and spent, reducing the risk of embezzlement or misuse.
• Trust Building: Transparency fosters trust between the government and its citizens. When people have access to information and can see how decisions are made, they are more likely to have confidence in government institutions.
  • For Example: Publishing government policies, decisions, and meeting minutes online ensures that citizens are informed and can participate in the democratic process.
• Efficient Resource Allocation: Transparent budgeting and procurement processes help ensure that resources are allocated efficiently and without favoritism. Competitive bidding processes and open contracts reduce the risk of corruption.
  • For Example: Public tenders and contracts are made publicly available, allowing businesses to compete fairly for government contracts, ultimately benefiting taxpayers.
• Preventing Corruption: Transparency acts as a deterrent to corruption. When government activities are transparent, it becomes more challenging for officials to engage in corrupt practices.
  • For Example: Whistleblower protection laws and mechanisms that allow citizens to report corruption anonymously encourage transparency by exposing corrupt activities.
• Citizen Engagement: Transparency enables citizens to participate actively in the decision-making process. Informed citizens can provide valuable input and hold their government accountable.
  • For Example: Public consultations and town hall meetings allow citizens to express their views on policies, regulations, and projects, influencing the decision-making process.
• Effective Service Delivery: Transparency ensures that government services are delivered effectively. Open access to service information helps citizens understand what services are available and how to access them.
  • For Example: Government websites with information about healthcare services, education, and social programs help citizens navigate available resources.
• Rule of Law: Transparency reinforces the rule of law by ensuring that government actions and policies align with established laws and regulations.
  • For Example: The publication of court decisions and legal precedents enhances transparency in the judicial system, demonstrating that justice is administered fairly and in accordance with the law.
• Foreign Investment: India’s efforts to improve transparency, particularly in economic and business-related matters, have attracted significant foreign investment. Initiatives like the “Make in India” campaign and reforms in ease of doing business rankings have enhanced the country’s appeal to foreign investors and donors.
• Economic Growth: Transparency in government procurement processes, licensing, and regulation has been critical in reducing corruption and inefficiency, contributing to India’s economic growth. For instance, the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) aimed at simplifying the tax system and increasing transparency in taxation.
• Conflict Prevention: Transparency in the administration of justice and access to information can help address grievances and reduce social and political conflicts. India’s Right to Information (RTI) Act empowers citizens to seek information from government agencies, promoting transparency and accountability.
• Quality of Life: Transparent governance has led to improvements in public services and infrastructure. The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan (Clean India Mission) is an example of a transparent and accountable initiative aimed at improving sanitation and quality of life for citizens.
• Environmental Conservation: The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change in India emphasizes transparency in environmental management. Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) are made public to ensure compliance with environmental regulations.
• Public Confidence: Transparency and accountability are crucial to maintaining public confidence in government institutions. Transparent allocation of resources and public spending builds trust. The government’s COVID-19 vaccination drive is an example of transparent communication and distribution efforts to maintain public confidence.
• Innovation and Development: Initiatives like the National Data Sharing and Accessibility Policy (NDSAP) have made government data accessible, fostering innovation and development in various sectors.
• Redressal Mechanisms: Transparent grievance redressal mechanisms, such as online portals and helplines, allow citizens to seek remedies for issues related to government services. The Public Grievance Portal is an example of such a mechanism.
• Social Inclusion: Transparency can help identify disparities and inequities in public policy and resource allocation. The socio-economic caste census and affirmative action policies in India aim to address social exclusion and discrimination through transparent means.
• Human Rights Protection: Transparency is essential in protecting human rights. The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) in India investigates human rights violations and promotes transparency and accountability in this context.

Accountability of Public Servants

Accountability of public servants in India is crucial to ensure responsible and transparent governance.

• Constitutional Provisions: The Indian Constitution lays down the framework for the accountability of public servants. Article 311 provides protection to civil servants from arbitrary dismissal, but it also outlines the process for imposing disciplinary actions.
• Civil Services Conduct Rules: Public servants in India are subject to various conduct rules that govern their behavior, ethics, and responsibilities. These rules set standards for conduct, integrity, and impartiality.
• Central Vigilance Commission (CVC): The CVC is an independent agency responsible for addressing corruption and maladministration in central government agencies. It monitors and investigates complaints of corruption against public servants.
• Anti-Corruption Laws: India has several anti-corruption laws, including the Prevention of Corruption Act, which hold public servants accountable for acts of corruption. These laws empower investigating agencies to take legal action against those involved in corrupt practices.
• Accountability to Elected Representatives: Public servants are accountable to elected representatives, including Members of Parliament (MPs) and Members of Legislative Assemblies (MLAs), who hold them responsible for the implementation of policies and programs.
• Disciplinary Proceedings: Public servants can face disciplinary proceedings for misconduct, negligence, or corruption. These proceedings may result in penalties, suspension, or dismissal, depending on the severity of the offense.
• Ombudsman Institutions: Some states have established Lokayukta institutions, which serve as ombudsmen to investigate complaints of corruption and maladministration against public servants.
• Right to Information (RTI) Act: The RTI Act allows citizens to access information held by public authorities, enhancing transparency and enabling citizens to hold public servants accountable.
• Public Grievance Redressal: Public servants are required to address grievances and complaints from citizens promptly through established grievance redressal mechanisms.
• Audits and Inspections: Government agencies are subject to regular audits and inspections by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India, ensuring financial accountability and transparency.
• E-Governance Initiatives: The use of technology and e-governance initiatives in India helps improve transparency, reduce corruption, and enhance accountability in public service delivery.
• Whistleblower Protection: The Whistleblowers Protection Act provides legal safeguards to individuals who report corruption and wrongdoing in the government sector, encouraging accountability.
• Performance Appraisal: Public servants are often subject to performance appraisals, which assess their efficiency, effectiveness, and adherence to rules and regulations.
• Code of Conduct: Many government departments and organizations have their own codes of conduct and ethical guidelines that public servants are expected to follow.
• Public Interest Litigation (PIL): Citizens and organizations can file PILs in courts to seek judicial intervention and hold public servants accountable for issues affecting the public interest.

Major Differences Between Transparency And Accountability